Canadiens Maple Leafs Rivalry Dead Or One Sided?

Maybe it’s just me but I found an article in the Montreal Gazette quite amusing. It seems that the Maple Leafs signing of Mike Komisarek has set off some nerves in the land of the Habs.

“Among the thoughts that avoided our delete key, posted before and after Komisarek signed a five-year, $22.5-million contract with the Maple Leafs:

– “I really don’t want to hate Komisarek’s guts, but I can see that’s where this is going.”

– “Mike, I wish you all the success the Leafs have enjoyed for the last 40-plus years!”

– “Good riddance, Komi. Welcome to hell.”

A few suggested that Habs heavyweight Georges Laraque should be instructed – ordered, even – to pummel Komisarek, that despicable traitor, during the new Leaf’s first shift against his old team.

A few deleted comments indelicately questioned the marital status of Komisarek’s parents upon his birth, or suggested that he engage in an activity that is anatomically impossible.”

Really? Now, do you think that is any different if he went elsewhere? I would imagine when a Boston Red Sox bolts and joins the New York Yankees similar things occur. Yes, I know the whole Leaf/Habs thing flared up last season with Grabovsky. My question is, do you really care about the Habs? Seriously, and maybe I am in the minority here, but if Sundin (I can’t think of some other life long Leaf) signed with Montreal last season, I wouldn’t have cared. I would care a lot more if he went to Ottawa, but the reality is there are few places a Toronto player could go that would motivate me to go to a newspaper website and post this type of stuff. When Curtis Joseph, one of my favourite Maple Leafs bolted to go to the Wings, one of my most despised teams growing up, I started to root for the Wings (except when playing the Leafs).

Am I alone in this?

I think the time for this type of stuff went out the door when the NHL expanded beyond 6 teams. Did Seinfeld have it right? Do we root for the clothes or the player? I think in most cases it’s the jersey. There are obviously exceptions. Once the puck drops though we want our team to win.

Is it an erosion of the Habs/Buds rivalry or is it that I just don’t care all that much? I don’t get overly jazzed to see the Leafs play the Habs. When they were in the playoffs last season I rooted for them and not because they were a Canadian team. I think that those of you older than me will say that you still despise the Habs, so maybe it’s a generational thing. I suspect that it’s an inferiority complex on the part of our friends up the 401. I mean, Their baseball team was taken from them, they don’t have a basketball team (do we?). All that is left on the MAIN stage is the Habs. The Nordiques were taken from them too. What remains of their age old rivals is Toronto and Boston. Ottawa is closer geographically, would the same hatred be spewed if Komisarek had signed with the Sens? Maybe our team’s failures have dulled the rivalry from this end.

Little TSM has no clue who the Habs are. He knows you boo the Senators, he roots like hell for Crosby and when he plays on his DS or PSP he wants to be the Leafs or the Pens. The only Maple Leaf he can name is Cliff (ya think he listens to his dad talking to LT too much?). Seriously, he couldn’t name one maple leaf, except maybe Cujo.

I find the Montreal perspective amusing. Am I out to lunch or are you like me?


Follow me on twitter at @yyzsportsmedia

Habs article is here

About the Author
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
July 3, 2009 10:37 am

I think it’s about to heat up a little bit.

Check this out:

July 3, 2009 10:54 am

While I’m a Leafs fan who enjoys the Habs/Leafs rivalry, I’ve always respected the class of the Canadiens organization and the fans…I’ve enjoyed a number of Leafs/Habs games in Montreal and the rivalry in the stands is respectful and fun. This guy is simply a clown. Fortunately; I don’t believe he’s the norm. Habs fans should call him out.

While the rivalry has less meaning than it had in the past and I don’t “despise” the Habs like I did as a kid – I still get excited when they play and enjoy the Leafs wins more when against the Habs.

July 3, 2009 11:22 am

Well the only thing I can compare it to was last year when I was mortified to learn that Mats Sundin was seriously contemplating signing with Montreal. Or so the rumours said.

It made me sick to my stomach, envisioning #13 with a Habs jersey on. They are probably my most hated of all teams, now that the Sens have become pretty much useless on so many levels.

Now I don’t know if Habs fans felt the same admiration that I did for Sundin before he left. Obviously some feel exactly like I did for that brief moment when I read ‘Sundin signing in Montreal Imminent – E5’…lmao. Hanky is seriously the worse…sorry, flashback.

When Habs played Boston this year I asked a buddy of mine who is diehard Bruins fan to borrow something because I wanted Montreal to lose, and horribly. And I laughed heartily when they did!! Couldn’t have asked for better, a sweep and not even close of a series.

I suppose some of it stems from the fact that I have some ‘annoying’ die hard Habs fans in my area that drive me absolutely crazy with the trash that comes out of their mouth. It literally fuels my hatred every time they speak.

Anyways, bottom line, no this guy ain’t crazy and yes I do believe some people get that upset when their favorite players play for the enemy (insert team name here).

July 3, 2009 11:24 am

I think the rivalry is diminished but not dead. These things tend to go in cycles. I have to say I still enjoy antagonizing habs fans whenever the opportunity is there. I had a great time watching the Boston/Mtl playoff series out at the bars. 😉

July 3, 2009 3:50 pm

Wait until both teams are contenders again at the same time

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x