Seen & Heard – Weekend Edition

Seen & Heard – Weekend Edition

photo: Russian “lesbian” band TATU performing at Sochi

by mike in boston [hatemailaccount -a-t- gmail /dot/ com] @mikeinboston

.

The Surreal Sochi Experience

 

Maybe I’m just getting old but winter seems to be dragging on with no end in sight and it’s making me cranky. Rob Ford continues to embarrass and Sochi is a clusterfuck. I cover LGBT(etc) issues here quite a bit so I won’t go in to the protests. As the Games get underway one thing many people will be watching for is whether medal-winning athletes will show support for the protesters. I hope they do.

The main thing I want to discuss is the level of sheer incompetence that seems to pervade the planning of these Olympics. I live in the States and the tone here is one of political Schadenfreude at all the mistakes. Even though the Cold War has been over for decades, many Americans still view Russia with mistrust. Canadian coverage has an element of this as well, but that’s mostly as a way of making ourselves feel better about the Gretzky torch lighting fiasco.

Since these games seem to be a vanity exercise for Putin that will cost the Russian taxpayers for generations, I think the amount of media coverage devoted to #Sochiproblems is fair. Every city/country that decides to host the Olympics should be held accountable for the white elephants they decide to build with public funds. In Russia’s case, despite being the most costly winter Olympics, they couldn’t manage to delay those criticisms until after the games. I guess that’s what missing manhole covers will do.

Bruce Arthur & Sean Fitzgerald are doing great work but @sochiproblems is the place to go to watch the disaster unfold from all angles.

.

CBS wins the NFL sweepstakes

 

Thursday night programming is where many U.S. networks live and die. CBS has just secured the rights to 8 NFL games for this fall on Thursdays and that is sure to shake things up. I’m a big fan of Nantz and Simms and so I like that CBS got the package. CBS is going to use the NFL to help promote its other shows, as well as secure its standing as a sports network. As I have mentioned in the past, I like that the NFL spreads its games around between networks. This provides choice to the consumer, and it keeps the networks competitive. No one can be too comfortable or stagnant when the games are on so many channels. This is why we see such great innovation in how the game is presented. The quality of an NFL broadcast is peerless in my opinion.

 

Rogers & the NHL

 

This leads to the other major media news this week. Rogers, who jus spent 5.2 billion dollars to become the main national network for the NHL in Canada, announced that they will be changing the focus of their NHL coverage.  Rather than spending time on the state of the game, they will highlight the players and the goals and the saves. Now, of course, this a great idea. People who like hockey care about what happens on the ice. The concern is that this will come at the expense of legitimate journalism on things like concussions and the financial health of the half dozen teams who seem to always been on the verge of collapse. I have written a lot about why I worry that the NHL having only one media partner would be bad for fans and this announcement raises further worries.

 

I’m a little disappointed that Chris Zelkovich didn’t discuss any of these concerns in his piece. For example, Chris writes “Canadian hockey broadcasters spend way too much time discussing business issues, [Moore] said, something that most fans aren’t interested in hearing about.” I think this is demonstrably false: when PHX was on the verge of coming the Hamilton people cared a lot about the business issues of the NHL. The same is true of what is going on in Quebec City, and what happened in Winnipeg.

 

What is true is that the NHL would prefer if journalists spent less time criticizing the health of the league, it’s issues with goons and dirty hits, and  impending litigation. To try to suggest that fans don’t care, and so Rogers is just trying to serve fan interest, is highly disingenuous.

 

If Rogers and its employees will no longer be covering these issues, this is a real opening for TSN and CBC. There is no reason not to cover both the on-ice and off-ice aspects of the sport, and as a viewer/reader/listener, I will be taking notice of how Rogers treats off-ice issues going forward. The appearance of bias is, as they say, just as worrisome as actual bias. Rogers opened itself up to the appearance of bias when it bid a ton to be the exclusive voice of the NHL. This announcement does nothing to dispel that appearance. Rather, it reinforces it.

 

Low Hanging Fruit – PTS Edition

 

When TSM asked which media member we would most like to be rid of many people mentioned PTS regulars as candidates who should walk the plank. This seems like as good a time as any to revisit PTS’ FOB problem. For those new to the site, ages ago the commenters coined the term FOB to refer to people appearing on PTS whose main credential is that they are Friends of Bob.

 

The original FOB was, I think, Gord Kirke. He is/was Bob’s agent. He was basically harmless, since he rarely contributed much. But when there was a discussion about free agency and contracts he occasionally had some insight. The next one I remember was the late Jim Kelley. He was an NHL writer for a Buffalo newspaper, and was most famous for being attacked by Domonic Hasek. Why was this person a regular co-host on PTS? You guessed it — FOB. He would drive me crazy as you would prattle on endlessly about the Jays or the NFL or whatever with zero expertise. Then there was this guy Brian Cooper who showed up out of nowhere for a while. His claim to fame was being a fundraiser of some sorts, but he often came on to discuss sports. Why? Who knows, but it was not good radio.

 

The most recent FOBs is by far the most disliked: John Shannon. He showed up a long time ago as an occasional guest to discuss the production side of the NHL when he was working for the league. I really enjoyed these segments as he was knowledgeable about a very technical subject. This led to a regular co-hosting gig where, as we all know, he is impossible to shut up. Whether he’s adding his own sound-effects or talking over guests, he’s by far the worst thing about PTS these days. More recently, Butch Carter has started to irk some commenters, largely for Shannon-like reasons. Like all FOBs, Butch would be fine as a guest on a topic about which he is credible. As we’ve discussed many times on this site, being a generalist is hard and few people can do it well.

 

When Nelson Millman kindly agreed to be interviewed for this site, he mentioned that he would talk to Bob just about every day and they would talk about the plan for the show and potential adjustments. The fact that the FOB problem has endured for the last 5-7 years or so makes me think this is a contractual issue. My guess is that Bob has a “FOB clause” that allows him to pick co-hosts. The addition of Brunt has been fantastic, but the remainder of the choices have been to detriment of the show. The reason Brunt is so great is, in part, because he makes Bob raise the level of his game. As many have noted, when Bob does one of those grumpily old man rants, Brunt just shuts right up and refuses to take the bait. The other co-hosts thrive on these pointless arguments, and it’s terrible terrible radio.

 

I’m sure the current program director is hearing the same thing we are hearing, and can’t be thrilled about the cast of hangers-on who drag the show down. Sadly, it seems that little will change until Bob retires. I wonder how much of his audience will have switched over to Naylor by that time. I’m a fan of the PTS I grew up with. I hope they find some way to recapture some of that in the time they have left.

 

thanks for reading and commenting,

until next time

mike (in boston)

COMMENTS

WORDPRESS: 19
  • comment-avatar

    Thanks MIB.

    On Sochi, I’ve been enjoying @cathalkelly ‘s feed for pictures and comments about his daily life at the Olympics.

    On Shannon, they can’t get rid of him fast enough (except for the once-per-two-months broadcasting segment. The good news is that he’s been quite limited lately – a welcome relief after an almost interminable string of appearances on the Friday roundtable. Sadly, I think he’s been on the last 2 or 3 in a row.

    On Kirke, I can’t say I enjoy his appearances but at least he has the good sense to keep quiet when he doesn’t have anything of relevance to say about a subject. Which seems to be most of them.

  • comment-avatar

    I jokingly told Ami yesterday that Brunt would be wastedon the roundtable this week, given Sid and Butch were the other two guests. It was not as bad as a Cox/Shannon roundtable, but id say only average.

    I wonder which PTS regualrs are in Sochi. I know Deitsch is there for SI. On 1050, i’ve heard Arthur, Kelly and FitzGerald on with Naylor or Macko/Cauz.

    BTW, i dont know how many Amercians post here other than Mike and I but 1050’s stream will be down except for Leafs games during the Olympics. I asked Naylor about it and it’s because of them dropping in Olympics audio. He thought the podcasts should still be available minus Olympics audio. All three hours of his podcasts showed up yesterday, so thats a good thing.

  • comment-avatar
    Drumanchor 6 years ago

    Funny, but I don’t really mind Shannon. I find most of his comments informative as he does have very broad background in sports and sports media.

    Now, when he was shilling for LeafsTV and seemed to be ALWAYS on PTS, I couldn’t change the station fast enough.

    (By the way, since Nelson Millman’s name was mentioned, I thought I would ask how he got to be shrined as some sort of demigod of sports radio. He ran the only game in town that employed some very lame broadcasters who would host shows for years. Also had more ads and updates per hour than programming. Seemed more interested in getting on the air himself.)

  • comment-avatar
    Bobby G 6 years ago

    Jim Kelley was also a Bills beat writer for many years so he spoke from expertise on that topic.
    Brian Cooper was president if the Argos under McNall-Gretzky-Candy. He now works in sports marketing and provides insight into those areas when he’s on.

  • comment-avatar
    (Another) Andrew 6 years ago

    As the Games get underway one thing many people will be watching for is whether medal-winning athletes will show support for the protesters.

    And they’ll all be lilly-white social striving bourgeois liberals who love American hegemony (but will never admit it). Nobody else on earth cares about the narcissistic (and occasionally pro-paedophile) LGBT agenda. Good grief. Reading the Corporate American media (and TSM) you’d think it was Putin who was the usurer of the world, the drone killer behind the slaughter of thousands of innocent Afghan, Pakistani and Yemeni civilians, the overseer of NSA aggressions, and the main revenue source propping up for Apartheid on the West Bank. That’s Obama, not Putin.

    Bruce Arthur & Sean Fitzgerald are doing great work

    I don’t know who Fitzgerald is but Arthur is the idiot who said on PTS that the South African World Cup would be a disaster. (OK, on the pitch it was indeed a disaster but that’s not what Arthur meant. He was referring to crime).

  • comment-avatar
    Another Steve 6 years ago

    “Nobody else on earth cares about the narcissistic (and occasionally pro-paedophile) LGBT agenda.”

    What the fuck?

  • comment-avatar
    Mullah_Kintyre 6 years ago

    I wonder if Ford saw the NFL Network’s “Football Life” episode about Jerry Smith.

  • comment-avatar

    Wow.

    A new low for the comments here

  • comment-avatar

    FOB! That, sadly, says it all when it comes to the dumbing down of what once truly was the premier sports talk radio show in North America. Pity.

  • comment-avatar

    What has, so far, made coverage of these Winter Olympics almost unbearable is the constant sniveling and whining of journalists – none of whom have paid a dime of their own money to get there.

    And, unfortunately, Canada’s representation in this area has been second to none. The facilities represented a legitimate story for about a day – now it’s nothing but phony wannabes like Cathal Kelly and Bruce Arthur trying to act pertinent when they can’t come up with anything original to write or say.

  • comment-avatar
    Steve Rogers 6 years ago

    Man what did Bob do to you? The weekly rants are becoming more nonsensical all the time. At least try and get you facts right. Cooper ran the Argos and has been involved in sports marketing for decades. Naylor is dull as dirt. A lousy interviewer and has a weak cast. Just admit it there is a vendetta here of some sort. And really, the PTS with Shakey was hardly great radio.

  • comment-avatar

    Steve Rogers — bias is often in the eye of the beholder, so there’s not much I’ll be able to say to convince you otherwise.

    I listen to both PTS and Naylor (on podcast) regularly. Like most people who grew up listening to PTS I have a huge amount of respect for Bob (and Dan Shulman) for the existence of the show and his contributions to the all-sports talk format. I just don’t think its current incarnation is very good (sans Brunt). As for Naylor’s show, there is a lot of room for improvement, especially with respect to the ludicrous amounts of time they devote to the CFL and NHL.

    As many readers have pointed out every time we discuss this, the choice often comes down to a choice of “shtick” vs “non-shtick”. I think Bob’s shtick requires a talented co-host in order to be successful, and he does not have talented co-hosts except for Brunt. I can see why people find Naylor dull compared to Bob, but I just have a preference for listening to intelligent and sincere debate on topics I find interesting.

    There was a time when PTS was the gold standard for intelligent sports talk, but that’s no longer the case in my opinion.

  • comment-avatar
    Derrick 6 years ago

    What’s with hate for Butch? I think he adds a lot of entertaining insight to the NBA, and the personalities of professional athletes. I really found his comments about how he handled the Raptors “Florida swings” entertaining and informative.

    He generally sticks to topics he knows and only comments on what he sees and provides his opinion.

  • comment-avatar
    Raptors Devotee 6 years ago

    I agree with Derrick. Butch Carter is completely truthful and uncensored with his comments, and I have been lobbying for years to hear more of him. Yes, he went postal as the Raptors coach with the whole threat of a law suit against Marcus Camby in the middle of the playoffs, but that was a long time ago, and has no bearing on his commentating, which I find both entertaining and informative.

    Butch offers a view into an athletes soul, and what makes them tick. Fascinating to hear what measures he took to make each one of his players perform to the best of their abilities and work within the team dynamic.

    Is Butch qualified to talk about other sports outside the NBA. I say yes, certainly better than the dribble coming out of most FOB’s. I look forward to his participation, and I couldn’t care less if you are a FOB, as long as you can be both informative and entertaining. Butch watches a lot of sports and pays attention to what is going on, and is topical when he puts his commentary forward, so what is the problem here?

  • comment-avatar
    sam in oshawa 6 years ago

    What courage for Michael Sams, bravo…

  • comment-avatar
    Lee (Oakville) 6 years ago

    Agree on Michael Sams. One of the most courageous things I’ve ever seen in sports.

  • comment-avatar

    (Another) Andrew: I believe this comment is pretty close to the mark. Most of these hypocritical journos love to hype a story if it creates a stir. Where was their outrage at the state of Aboriginals in this country when Canada hosted the last winter Olympics? Answer: they didn’t give a shit.

  • comment-avatar
    Antonio 6 years ago

    @Omar
    Actually our natives have it pretty good. I wish there was more outrage over the oppressive regime in China back in 2008. Of course, its “special” when it involves gay people so the MSM makes it a huge story. Frankly, I’m sick of it.

  • comment-avatar

    I’m trying to determine what my favourite Butch Carter moment from Friday’s PTS roundtable was…………I’ve narrowed it down to these two:

    1) When they were talking about the Olympics and Butch referred to the Russian president as “Putkin”

    2) When they were talking about the Jays and Butch referred to them several times as “we”